What my father wrote about his life.
He died Feb 15, 2004 after a short illness.
I have found this printed history and scanned it in using OCR (Optical Character Recognition) so there could be mistakes in the text that he would not have made, I will correct them soon but they are here for interested people who knew him to read. What you read below is all written by him and I find interesting.
Funeral Thursday Feb. 26, 2004. Mortlake Crem 3.30pm
Notes on my Life
A casual history for the Butler family 's record.
1. I left Colston's School in Bristol in 1939 with a reasonable School Certificate and no idea what I
wanted to do for a living. I eventually took an apprenticeship in a chemist's shop. It was not my
metier. A number of people told me that I didn't look right standing behind the counter in a white
coat. There is no doubt that in my eighteen months there I learned very little pharmacy (I was
cheap labour on the counter) but I did learn some interesting things. For instance, I found that the
day passed much more quickly if I made a real effort to be exceptionally helpful to the customers,
however trying they were. I also learned how to dress a shop window even given the unpromising
collection of boxed bottles and pills, with the odd tin of "Flit", some suppositories, dog-flea
remedies and the rest. Unmentionable things like sanitary towels were dispensed by the women
who served on the cosmetics counter across the shop The shop sold no contraceptives except
Mrs Rendall's Pessaries.
2. On the first day of January 1941 [ had been eighteen for six weeks and the German Air
Force was entering on a series of raids on my home town of Swansea that was to destroy the centre
entirely. I presented myself at the R.A.F recruiting office and signed on in the RAF Volunteer
Reserve 'for the duration of hostilities' as a trainee pilot. A few weeks later I was summoned to a
medical examination at Keble College, Oxford. There I learned that my rib cage has a slight
congenital malformation when the young doctor who was doing the examination called over his
equally young colleague. "Look - some-one or other's skeleton!" he exclaimed. I wish 1 could
remember who the some-one was He spent a while checking where my heart was before telling me
that I was lucky, this condition often pressed upon the heart and deformed it, but I was clear of
problems. I had evidently made his day and his chum's by providing a living example of something
rare that must have been included in their fairly recently completed course. After that I was
declared accepted for aircrew training and sent home to await call-up papers. No other doctor has
ever noticed this rare skeletal aberration.
3. Months went by after this medical without a word from the Air Force. When the
Summer vacation came the University Air Training Corps put a notice in the South Wales Evening
Post that they were opening the initial training course, that they were just starting, to outsiders who
had the necessary aircrew acceptance. I was there like a shot- This course gave exemption, when
one was eventually called in, to the six week Initial Training Wing (the ITW). The course was
conducted by a University don assisted by a Flight Sergeant Air Gunner with a Distinguished Flying
Medal earned manning the pathetic pan-fed machine gun mounted at the back of the hopelessly
obsolete two-seater Fairy bomber that the RAF had been using to defend ground forces in the
retreat to Dunkirk. He still kept the old battle-dress jacket that he had been wearing when he was
sprayed with machine gun bullets by some passing Messerschmidts and he got it out to show us the
scattering of bullet holes. From the fact that he had been decorated one can assume that not all the
Me's got home. He had just come out of hospital when he was given this cushy posting, to
recuperate
4. This air gunner's grasp of the importance of military discipline was no better than that of
any other aircrew so we never learned to march properly, salute smartly or do any of the other
tedious things that every-one who had had to attend a formal ITW could at least do if they tried.
The University don taught us what the book said we needed by way of rudimentary navigation, but
in my case only just We had to gain at least 60 in the mathematics paper at the end of the course
and I was never any good at sums - in School Certificate I was given only a "Pass" rather than the
"Credits" and "Distinctions" that the other subjects earned me (I've just remembered that the
Bristol examination board had just dropped the term "Distinction" and substituted "Very Good"
presumably not wishing us to get above ourselves). Anyhow, when the results of our ITW
exemption exam came out I had passed, but with a bare 60 in maths. I have the abiding
impression that the Prof, who marked the papers himself, had massaged my maths results so that 1
could scrape through, the rest of my scores being pretty good.
5 It was December before I was formally called up. The RAF had taken over many of the
massive blocks of flats fronting on to Regents Park in St.John's Wood to house the flood of new
aircrew recruits and here I found that "No 1 Flight" had been composed entirely of people who had
been through a University Air Squadron training in place of ITW. Meals were taken in what had
been the restaurant in the zoo, and the hundreds of other new entrants were lined up in flights along
the approach road, awaiting their turn to enter. We, however, having completed our basic training
were all promoted to Leading Aircraftmen and thus glorified we were marched past the waiting
hundreds to eat first although the last to arrive. I ought to have felt it was quite unfair but
somehow I couldn't, although the ribald remarks shouted at us, as we shambled by in clear evidence
that we were not fit to be let out in the King's uniform where people could see us, should have
shamed us.
6 This did not last long. We were transferred to civilian billets in Manchester to await
shipping to Canada and thence to the USA to be taught to fly by the US Navy at Pensacola. This
was under a scheme known as "Towers Chuck" There was an Admiral Towers in the US Navy so
perhaps he had some hand in it - but "Chuck"? Perhaps it was the admiral's nickname. Anyhow,
we had to paint it on the side of each of our three kit bags (Two big ones for our normal uniform kit
and a smaller one for the as yet unused flying gear). On Christmas Eve 1941 we were transferred to
the docks at Gourock and put on board a large Norwegian cargo vessel called the "Rei-yensftorif'.
Inside we found that below decks had been cleared and long dining tables with backless seating
benches occupied the whole space Above each table there were sturdy hooks from which at night
we were to sling the hammocks that were issued. I believe I recall correctly that there were three
thousand of us swaying beneath those hooks, every hammock touching two or three others,
throughout the entire length and breadth of what I suppose had been the cargo deck.
7 Things did not seem too bad until the morning - Christmas morning! - when the ship hit
the open sea just as we were hitting the deck Ugh! The smell of sea-sick pervaded the whole ship
for most of the three weeks it took us to reach Halifax, Nova Scotia Few of us could keep
anything down. I spent most of my time up on the deck in the freezing wind - so did most people.
Some-one told me there were three people down below for the Christmas dinner. I can only
suppose their fathers owned sea-going yachts on which their stomachs had been broken in to the
ocean's heaving. For the first week or so we had an escort of two of the old four-funnel destroyers
supplied by the Americans in return for bases in the Caribbean. These ancient warships were out of
sight for most of the time, just the tops of their many funnels showing above the great waves. The
North Atlantic in Winter is not recommended but my resolve to have nothing to do with the open
sea ever more was defeated a year later - but you will read of that later on.
8 Halifax was a shock! Bright lights visible for miles out at sea! After more than two
years of strictly enforced black-out it seemed like fairy land. We were put straight on to a train to
take us to Moncton in New Brunswick. Here there was in the course of completion a huge holding
centre to receive the coming flood of aspiring aviators. The snow was thick on the ground but the
barracks were sadly overheated by a system that used steam in radiators, although we did not know
it. That night, finding no way of adjusting the temperature in the barracks we opened the windows,
only to awake in the morning near frozen. What a fuss there was! The Canadians could not
believe anyone could be so stupid as to condense the steam in the heating system. To their credit
they had the place warm again by night fall. To pass the time we were put on to polishing the miles
of newly laid flooring - the experience of handling a large electric polisher was to be repeated in a
Brighton hotel a year later; it just demonstrates the truth of the saying that war is 99 boredom
relieved only by rare episodes of terror
9. We were in Moncton for some weeks. Happily one of my chums was a Baptist and
thus very welcome in the New Brunswick community. We soon got to know a friendly family with
two daughters and a niece with whom we were taken skating, given meals at home and on one
disgraceful occasion repaid them by pulling their legs. 1 asked one of the girls what was her work.
She was a Comptometer operator "What's that'7" says I, tongue in cheek. "It's an adding machine"
says she. "Don't be daft" says my good friend Jim Andrew, picking up my line straight away, "If
there were machines to add up we needn't go to school". We kept up this pretence of frank
disbelief until they rang a man friend to ask him to come over and explain to these pathetically
ignorant English! From the look on her face the girls' mother had rumbled us, but she said nothing.
In the end we had to confess it was a leg pull but it says something for the understanding of things
in the U.K. that we could con them for so long. We were forgiven but nothing we said was taken at
face value thereafter.
10. This very hospitable family, whose name I have to my shame forgotten, took us to the
Sunday service in the huge, modem Baptist chapel. There was a sizeable gallery upstairs where we
had to sit, having arrived late One wall of the main hall could be folded back to make the large side
room available to extend the auditorium when, as on Sundays, the crowd was too great to be
accommodated in the main chapel. The preaching was pretty forthright. "The Sunday collection
here is now averaging only two dollars a head and this is supposed to be a Christian community!"
was one example I remember. They were all strictly tee-total and actually pointed out to me a
neighbour's car, saying, "Do you know, in the boot of that car they bring home liquor'" They were
quite seriously shocked.. I was to see them again on my way home a year later, and join in the New
Year's night service, and I have the warmest memories of these good-hearted Canadians and their
snowy township -1 suppose it looks quite different in the Summer but I can only imagine it against
a white background.
11 After a few weeks we were put on a train for Detroit. There there was a U. S.Navy
airfield with no made up runways, it was just an enormous field - or I suppose it was a field, we
never saw what lay underneath the packed snow that covered everything. The snow had all been
flattened by road rollers, so that we had a firm white table on which to take our first flying lessons,
the direction in which we landed being dictated by the wind-sock.. The aircraft were large yellow
two sealer bi-planes, open cockpits with no proper intercom, just a speaking tube in the instructor's
helmet that fed into the ear-pieces in our helmets. He could speak to us and we had no need to
speak to him, we just did as we were told. Any-one who could not learn to fly solo in eight hours
was sent packing, presumably to be given training in some other aircrew trade in Canada. Apart
from one short visit to Detroit we had no time off, and as soon as we had all solo'd we were put on
the train South.
12. The train to Pensacola, in Florida, was an eye-opener Slow moving, when it stopped at
some small station for the engine to take on water the mob of young English lads pouring out to
buy everything edible in the little station shop must have been an alarming sight We were two or
three days on the way. The carriages transformed at night into long corridors lined with curtains
closing off the two tiers of sleeping bunks. We gained a fascinating view of the variety of the
American countryside, the train occasionally passing slowly down the middle of a small country
town's main street, to our absolute amazement. We would spend hours passing across an
enormous plain, then more hours in dark pine forest, the snow vanishing as we moved further
South.
13 Pensacola itself was a small hick town, (rather bigger when I saw it 53 years later with a
group of other ex-RAF characters on a nostalgic return visit). On a promontory off to the right of
the bay there was, and still is, a U.S. Naval Air Base There we were housed in one of the large
brick buildings. The dormitory that my intake was assigned to was known as "Compartment I". 1
can still hear the strong Southern accent of the seaman in the duty office as he called over the
loudspeakers calling the attention of "Compartment Ah" to some official announcement or other.
Our beds were steel double bunks. On the walls were large G.E. electric fans swinging back and
forth, not really needed when we moved in in February but very soon most welcome as the weather
warmed and became extremely humid. These fans turned day and night without stop throughout
the months that I was there, quite a tribute to General Electric.
14. We were bussed out to one of the three outlying airfields for flying training.. It had a
huge area of tarmac where three massively wide runways converged. We all had to go through the
initial training again, only allowed to fly solo after some hours of dual. Here, we were flying over
the enormous marshes of the North Florida coast. We were taught to stunt, to land on very small
fields surrounded with tall bushes (it was, of course, a programme basically designed to prepare
naval people for carrier landings eventually) and above all not to loose our bearings and not to lose
sight of the other 'yellow perils' also being thrown around the skies. We followed the fashion and
each bought ourselves a cheap pocket watch which we hung around our necks on a boot lace when
we were flying - it was important not to lose track of the time for we were all expected back at the
end of an hour One of the hair-raising memories is of the mob of about eighty yellow bi-planes,
mostly flown by learners with only a few hours flying practice, all jockeying for position as they
came in to land, like a flock of starlings, on the huge expanse of tarmac. Another abiding memory
is of the way that the cheap watch, strung around the neck on the long bootlace, would hang down ; ''^/"'i; ',.'
in front of your eyes when you were hanging upside down in the middle of a loop or a slow roll.
15. We were worked hard. Woken at six o'clock, then straight after breakfast either out to
the airfield or into a lecture room - or occasionally to the excellent engine sheds, each of which held
a large radial engine rigged up so that with the pull of a wire some typical engine defect could be
brought about. One demonstrated the effect of carburettor icing; this I was able to recognise two
years later as someone described the slow falling away of their plane's speed over the Atlantic
despite the opening wide of the throttle. Interestingly enough they were only saved from disaster as
the aircraft descended closer and closer to the sea because one of the crew, the second pilot,
(something we had on Coastal Command, although never on Bomber) had also been at Pensacola
and had suddenly recalled the lesson learned in those engine sheds and the remedy, which was to
press a button marked 'spot heater'. It was my own crew but I had a head cold and had been
replaced for this trip. I felt a pang of jealousy, 1 would have loved to be the Smart Alee who saved
the day by recognising the cause when all others were flummoxed! The lucky man who did save the
day was called Alee Haslam (a truly smart Alee!) I have just remembered. I wonder where he is
now.
16 When we arrived at Pensacola the weather had been dank , damp with sea mist rolling
oft'the Gulf of Mexico. As the year wore on it rapidly warmed up and we were dressed in khaki
trousers held up with U.S.Marines' black belts. Air Force blue shins with the standard black tie and
our fore-and-aft R.A.F. caps. I still have my marine's belt somewhere, I'm sure. One day I was
amazed to find myself covered in spots I had German Measles' There was an isolation wing and
there 1 was in company of one Frank Garner who had contracted scarlet fever (how the names come
back!) He was a married man with a house in Pinner and I was to meet him once just after the war,
when he told me that on returning to the U.K. he had found his wife had gone off with another man.
We were kept apart in separate rooms, but after a few days we spent our days together despite the
instructions of the medical people. They were a bit panic struck when it came out that we sitting
together in each other's rooms -1 suppose the thought of people perhaps infected with both scarlet
fever and measles at the same time was not comforting, but it didn't worry us.
17 Back home the R.A.F. was re-equipping with four-engined bombers in their thousands,
and the word was passed down to the training airfields that half the half-trained pilots were to be
transferred to Canada to be made into Navigators, Bomb-aimers or Radio operators. I had
completed just a hundred hours of pilot's training and was very disappointed to be stopped. At the
R.C.A.F. station at Trenton we were given aptitude tests, intelligence tests, interviews and anything
else that caught the imagination. 1 was told off to make my way to the Central Navigation School
in Rivers, Manitoba and there was just time to complete the three month Navigation course before
Christmas - but before going back to England there was a little leave which I took in Toronto.
18 In Toronto 1 had an introduction from my father to one of his suppliers, Coro Jewellery
(Cohen & Rosenburger Inc.) and the Company Secretary there was a charming elderly woman who
had come out from England many years before. Miss Maywood, who would lend me her car and
introduced me to a Mrs Macdonald and her pretty daughter, Jean. The company even put me up at
the palatial Royal York Hotel together with my chum Ivor Morgan (Ivor was in the Navy and they
were allowed to resume pilot training in Canada, to my chagrin). Jean Macdonald was, I think, a
year or two older than I was (I was just twenty). We knocked around a bit together, both in that
first January and at Christmas when I was once more in Toronto on my way home, but she was
engaged to a soldier who was fighting in Europe and was not about to get too involved with a
passing Englishman, although she was kind enough to shed a tear when saying 'Goodbye' at the
station.. We corresponded for a year or two after I returned to the U.K. but when the troops
returned home she soon stopped writing - the last letter was from her as a married woman, Mrs
Jean Macdonald Bennett. It was all quite Platonic and really rather sweet. I hope Soldier Bennett
was good to her.
19. Learning to navigate out on the prairies was quite absorbing and I was good at it,
although not in the first half dozen in the class. At the end of the course I was invited to stay
behind in Canada and become an instructor Like a fool I at once declined. Commissions were
then handed out to the top few in the examinations, which I did not quite achieve, but I suppose
that my agreement to stay and teach would have secured the little thin ring on my sleeve. I can't
pretend it would have made a great deal of difference, aircrew NCOs were paid as much as junior
officers and our messing arrangements were not noticeably different, so not being given to status
chasing I easily shrugged it oft'.
20. By the time we finished our Navigator's course the weather had turned Arctic, with
deep snow and a dry but very deep cold. There was once more a chance for some leave in Toronto,
on the way home. We nearly missed Christmas, because the train bringing us from the prairies,
which we picked up in Brandon, the nearest real town to Rivers, was two days late in reaching
Toronto. Of course as the timetable suggested four days for this journey, the extra two days was
not quite as staggering as it would be in the U.K. Coro did not offer to put ^up again, but iwr
a-ft41 stayed at a little hotel near the station. I f-annnii_rempmhp.i_how-hi- p,mir.l liigfimr l-n^f was
taken in hand by the Macdonald family and spent Christmas day with the manager of Cohen &
Rosenburger and his family (I think he may have been related to the Macdonalds).
21 Returning to England was not as uncomfortable as the voyage out. We were put on the
train to New York, where we boarded the newly completed "Queen Elizabeth", and this went
tearing across the Atlantic, flat out, vibrating everywhere, unescorted at the height of the U-boat
menace, and arrived in Goiirock in just over three days. We were accommodated nine to a cabin, in
triple-decker bunks in what had been a first class cabin. There was an old Cunard steward who
would come around trying to keep an eye on the polished woodwork and see that these rough
servicemen did not damage his lovely cabins
22. . We used to start queuing for our meals an hour or more before we could get in to the
huge dining room. 1 remember us sitting on the floor in the corridors and shifting our bottoms
along on the polished surface as we slowly approached the dining room where long tables had been
set, probably a dozen or so people on benches on each side. The tables were athwart the ship, and
as she rolled in the winter Atlantic swells the tables tipped at an alarming angle. On one occasion
the roll was so extreme that the huge metal coffee jug that was supplied to our table started to slide
down the length of the table, pushing aside condiments and anything else in the way in a sort of bow
wave and shot off the end into the arms of a passing airman. Luckily he was able to catch it and
keep it upright. That coffee was hot and 1 imagine he would been a hospital case if it had spilt on
him. I only remember us lining up for one meal a day, in the late afternoon; if we had breakfast I
don't remember it but I don't remember going hungry either It is all too long ago!
23. A couple of us went exploring the lower decks one day. We found that all the cabins
had been taken out in order to accommodate the many thousands of American troops who were
being carried (was it twenty thousand9). There were just massive wooden structures, floor to
ceiling, with what were little more than shelves about two feet high which made bunks for the
troops - all we saw were negroes. The bunks appeared to be pretty well continuous, side by side,
perhaps three alongside each other before a gap occurred. I don't know if there was any way they
could get out on to a deck. In any event it must have been a fairly unattractive way to cross the
sea. If a U-boat had managed to lie across our path and put a torpedo into us... well, it does not
bear thinking about. Happily the ship was going at some thirty knots and we reckoned, rightly, that
it was not likely that anything would be able to molest her, a view presumably shared by the powers
that be.
24. I remember standing on deck against the aft rail, beautifully polished it was, and j
watching the great wake stretching straight for miles behind us. This was in January l^§fc. Years A- r
later I read that in the course other war-time journeys as a troop ship that rail became covered with
initials carved into the wood by servicemen , and that it is preserved somewhere as a memento.
Presumably the Cunard line have it.
25. Landing in Britain in January 1943 was a nasty shock. Things had been pretty austere
when I had left a year ago but now it seemed very seedy - of course I had the bright lights of North
America in my mind still, but it wasn't just the blackout (it is hard now to visualise a town with no
street lights, no lit shop windows, every house with heavy curtains or cardboard shutters across the
windows at night and thus no artificial light visible throughout the long Winter nights). What really
struck home was the dreariness of the shops, and in the North of England the appalling food in the
cafes - we were first put into accomodation in Harrogate, a building with 20-watt lamps on the
landings, shedding the dimmest, gloomiest glow you can imagine, and to get a meal in town meant
accepting Spam and potatoes and weak coffee. There seemed to be nothing else on offer.
26. From Harrogate we were soon transferred to Brighton. What a difference! We were put
up in one of the grand hotels - perhaps it was The Grand, I cannot remember, maybe The
Metropole - and our dignity as Senior NCOs was not offended by being put to polishing the floors
in the corridors with great electric revolving brushes. Wandering the shops in Brighton passed the
time. I remember playing chess in a hospitable chess club above a tea shop (they had a notice in the
window welcoming servicemen) and it was in Brighton then that I bought my first typewriter, a
small portable, and a pocket chess set. The beach was out of bounds, big notices reminded us that
it had been mined. While we were there my parents enjoyed their twenty-fifth wedding anniversary
and I bought them a pair of solid silver serving spoons in a shop in the town.
27. The civilised comfort of Brighton was quickly exchanged for more of the rigours of the
North. The RAF evidently had over-provided for replacement aircrew and we were not wanted on
an operational squadron for the time being, so we were sent to do a month's combat course under
the care of the RAF Regiment, mostly conducted on the cliff top in Whitley Bay. It was freezing
cold February weather and one day when were having our third lesson in the mysteries of the Sten
gun from our corporal instructor it came on to snow. "Should we not go indoors9" was the
question. He looked outraged. "Air Cahncel Instructions and King's Reggilations state that
instruction shall proceed under cover in the case of precipitation" he informed us. '"Precipitation
means rain. This 'ere is snow. Nah - the Sten Machine Carbine consists of free parts, the barrel
piece, the breech piece and the buf piece. Nah, Sarn't, can you tell me what are the parts of the
Sten Machine Carbine?" This was lesson three. Lessons one and two were much simpler. All
lessons occupied forty minutes. They were certainly not easily forgotten.
28. We were eventually released to return to Brighton to await posting for further training
In the middle of May it came. Two weeks at an Advanced Flying Unit at Staverton in Gloucester
covered, I see from my log book, as well as map reading, the elements of dead reckoning, astro-
navigation and other items rehearsing all that the navigation course had covered in Canada. The
flying was done in ancient Ansons..
29. How and where we passed our time in June I cannot tell. In early July I was flying in the
fabric-covered Wellington bombers, now being released from operations as the four engined
Sterlings came in to use, followed by Halifaxes and Lancasters. This was at the conversion flight at
a 3 Group Operational Training Unit at Edgehill, also in Gloucester. Here we were told to mingle
with the other brands of aircrew and make up a crew of our own choice consisting of a pilot, who
would captain the crew, a navigator, a bomb-aimer, a flight engineer, a radio operator and two air
gunners. Rather willy-nilly what coalesced was a crew consisting of an Australian called Skirving
as pilot, me as Navigator, Don Bamendas Bomb-aimer, Les Weddle as Engineer, Gordon
Stromberg to run the radio and two gunners, Fred Carey and Colin Drake. Bament and Drake were
also Aussies. All were NCOs.
30. Sergeant Skirving was not a success. His relations with the rest of us were so strained
that after six weeks, when we had been posted to a branch of the same O.T.U. at Chipping Warden,
we decided that we would somehow have to dump him and seek a change. For all of us to go as a
group to the C.O. would have constituted a serious offence, officially mutiny, so I was deputed to
go alone with our complaint. The C.O. had every-one called in to his office, where Skirving
launched into a litany of complaints about the abilities of his crew. The C.O. simply rang the
leaders of each trade for a quick opinion on the merits of each of us, while we stood before him.
Each one was 'above average'. The boss said he wanted no more of this, would we each agree to
continue together. Luckily he first asked Skirving, who shook his head. He enquired no further.
Skirving was told he would be found another crew, but he was still hanging around the station un-
crewed when we left a fortnight later.
31 The following day we were allocated another pilot, who had himself been dumped by his
crew. This was Lou Greenburgh, a commissioned Canadian, a Flying Officer. In his case the last
straw for his crew had been when on a training flight he, without warning, practised a surprise and
violent avoidance manoeuvre just as one of the crew was approaching the Elsan at the back of the
aircraft and upended the thing over the poor man's head. We hoped we would find him agreeable
mdfaut de mieux we made no demur. He was a terrible line-shooter and would not have been our
first choice but he shared all our adventures on Bomber Command and ended up with a D.F.C. -
and then a bar to the thing after evading capture when he was shot down over France (this was after
I had been taken off operations and was training as a meteorologist and after Weddle and Bament
had had to bale out during my last trip on bombers).
32. With Lou we were posted first to a Sterling squadron (No 620) at Chedburgh, a wind-
swept, bitterly cold spot in East Anglia on the road from Bury St.Edmunds to Haverhill, where the
RAF had built a group of widely dispersed Nissen Huts around an airfield. In the four weeks we
were on this squadron we did no more than two ' nursery slopes' trips, laying mines in the sea lanes
off Denmark. This was just as well, the Sterling was at the end of its operational life, unable to
climb higher than 16,000 feet when the Lancasters and Halifaxes were now operating at over
20,000 feet. The rate of losses (the "chop rate'' we called it) in attacks on Germany was running at
around 10 a night, when the much more successful Lancasters were suffering about 5 a night.
At home on leave for my birthday on the 19th November a telegram came to the house. It was for
me. '"Return to Base this day" was all it said.
33. Back at Chedburgh that night the C.O. addressed the Squadron. Stirlings were being
taken oft'bombing and transferred to glider towing, but without us. He was "Pleased and proud" i
to tell us thajall of the 620 Squadron crews were to go to Waterbeach, an airjield just North of ^
Cambridge, to be retrained on Lancaster Mark Us, which were equipped with the same Hercules
radial engines as the Stirling had, in place of the normal in-line Merlins. They were almost as good
as the Merlin-equipped Marks I & III, although stilt stuck a thousand or so feet below the rest of
the Lanes, but at least in company with the Halifaxes We were glad, although we could have done
without the other Lancasters dropping their bombs down through us. I almost wrote "through our
formations" but of course, unlike the U.S. Air Force, we did not fly in formation, each aircraft
having its own navigator who guided the plane in the dark along the route ordained for that night's
sortie. It says something for the system that we managed to get 800 or so aircraft over a target in
the space often minutes on most nights.
34. At Waterbeach we were just able to complete the conversion course on to Lancasters
before Christmas, be transferred to 514 Squadron, which operated from the same airfield, and get a
fortnight's leave which happily covered the whole of Christmas, returning on December the 29th to
find ourselves on the battle order for that night, target Berlin, known to all as The Big City. What
no-one had told us was that the Lancasters used on the Conversion Unit although almost identical
with those on the squadron were not exactly so The difference showed up when we were airborne
and I reached up to turn on that marvellously accurate navigation aid, the G-box. The switch was
not there! Fortunately the plan called for us to climb to height over the airfield before setting oft'.
During that climb there was a certain air of panic. If the switch was not found we would have to
abort and return in ignominy to the airfield. Fortunately Gordon Stromberg on his hands and knees
came across the switch screwed to the underside of the desk as some undocumented mod that was
doubtless supposed to be helpful.
35 My log book for the 29th December 1943 gives the aircraft as S' which was normally
used by another crew, as we had not yet been allocated our own craft. It also records "Three
combats, one enemy aircraft damaged, probably destroyed' followed by "Ditched in North Sea"
The flying time is recorded as 6 hours 30 minutes. One of the crew to which that aircraft properly
belonged turns up at the annual squadron reunion at Waterbeach and he never fails to remind me of
the distress we caused them by letting their beloved "S sugar" sink to the bottom of the North Sea.
I respond that the damned thing wasn't really much good, when its petrol tanks got a few holes in
them over Germany it just gave up the ghost after a few hours and stopped flying. Small things
amuse us in our old age.
36 For ditching I took up position on a bench in the fuselage with my back against the
bulkhead to the wireless cabin. I plugged in my intercom ready to pass a message to the pilot when
I was given a signal by the wireless operator His task was to come through the door from his cabin
but hold it open and shine his torch on the ammeter on his set. There was an aerial trailing beneath
the aircraft and when it hit the water the shorting would show up on the meter. When that
happened the w/op was to smack my leg, close the door and put his back against it, and I was to
say down my intercom "Forty feet!" which got over the driver's problem of landing on the sea in
the pitch dark. Well, that's the theory What actually happened was that when the w/op came
through his door he leant over and shouted in my ear "I've lost my bloody torch!'' It was when I
was passing this message to the pilot that we flew straight into a damned great wave and came to a
dead stop. My head hit the bulkhead and the next thing I knew was a voice from an open hatch over
my head enquiring kindly "Aren't you coming0"
37. We were fifteen hours in a crowded little rubber dinghy that winter's night and through
the morning into the early afternoon, the seven of us. I felt that some cynical boffin had decided to
keep those dinghies to their smallest possible dimensions by assuming that if an aircraft was so
damaged that it had to ditch there would almost certainly not be a chance of all seven men getting
out. We were crammed around the perimeter crushed shoulder to shoulder. There was a half gale
blowing, a huge swell with foam capping every wave, and we were all sea-sick within a few
moments. The dinghy being perfectly round the shape forced all our legs to cross at the knees, in
the middle. Every half hour or so the owner of the bottom legs would begin to holler and we would
bring our knees up so that his legs could take their turn on the top of the heap. Because I had taken
a blow on the head when we landed I seem to have drifted in and out of consciousness during the
night and I soon developed a monumental bruise down the side of my face which can be seen in the
picture that the local newspaper took of me when I arrived home (they wrote up quite a dramatic
story of the local boy's near escape, but it was killed by the censor - somewhere I must have the
galley proof that my father was given to prove that his old journalist drinking partner had really
tried.)
38. When we were eventually picked up by the Air-Sea Rescue launch about two in the
afternoon the crew, on learning how long we had been in the water, were astonished that we could
all still stand up unaided. It was, after all, mid-winter, blowing a gale and the sea was icy. What
made us so sturdy I cannot imagine. We never took exercise and had only our normal battledress
on - except of course for the gunners, who had thick canvas overalls and wore special woollen
underwear, they being the only people who were not normally in the nicely heated cabin. The rest
of us were soaked to the skin by the waves of cold water that would every now and again break
over the dinghy. I put our sturdiness down to the fact that no-one tried to be hearty, calling for a
singsong or trying to raise our spirits. We just sat there soaking wet gloomily waiting for time to
pass and, I suppose, thus conserving our energy.
39. Almost unbelievably not one of us caught a cold, although there was one minor casualty
when we were dropped a spare dinghy by the ASRS plane that found us; when we got into it and
were hauling on board the big packs of warm clothing that came down with it one was dropped on
Drake's foot, the only one in the boat without a boot on it (it had fallen off when he slipped as he
was getting from the plane into the dinghy). This kept him in the sick bay for a week or so while
we all went off on leave.
40 The launch was a converted high-speed torpedo boat but it still took four hours to get
back to Great Yarmouth in the teeth of the gale - we had ditched seventy miles from land. We all
slept throughout that journey despite the hammering the boat took as it leapt from wave to wave.
The bunks we were sleeping on were little more than shelves built against the side of the boat; I
discovered later that both my hips had bruises on them, caused as I bounced up and down, fast
asleep in the bunk. Waiting for the launch crew when we docked was a telex of commendation for
having managed to get to us in such weather.
41 In the hospital in Great Yarmouth, where we were put to bed on landing, a nurse came
to ask us what we would like for supper Colin Drake, a true Aussie, said "Steak and eggs"
without regard to the fact that steak was a real rarity and eggs were strictly rationed. To every-
one's amazement the nurse just nodded and twenty minutes later returned with the goods. We had
had no food for 24 hours and this was a very welcome breaking of a long fast.
42. In the morning we were told that the Wing Commander commanding 514 squadron (his
name was Sampson (I seem to remember) was flying over himself to pick us up. We had been
provided with warm blue woollen overalls in substitution for our soaking wet clothes. When we
arrived back at Waterbeach it was near lunchtime and the Wingco invited us all in to the bar in his
mess for a few strong drinks. (Very privileged! Rough NCOs in the Officers Mess bar!) That
night the Medical Officer gave each of us a sleeping pill, the famous "yellow torpedo", to make sure
we slept. No problem! In the morning we were issued with a leave pass for fifteen days - by
tradition, one day for every hour in the drink I had an uncle Ralph, a widower, my father's eldest
brother, who lived in Radlett with his two daughters. Winks and Celia, (I wonder where they are
now9) and his spinster sister, Hattie. I rang them and got myself invited for the night rather than set
about the long wartime journey down to Swansea.
43 I was conscious when I got to the house in Radlett that, although I had changed into
fresh clothes, I had brought with me a haversack containing the drenched gear I had been wearing,
hoping to get my mother to wash it, and it really stank of sea water. My aunt rang the folks at
home and told them I was with her and suggested that I stay over the next day, which was a
Sunday, and go home on Monday. On Sunday morning my uncle Ralph, who was a colonel (well,
perhaps a Lt.Col.) in the Royal Engineers with a job in the War Office, took me up to his golf club
and bought me a pink gin - my very first - and introduced me to his friends, rather evidently full of
pride in his nephew, so very recently dragged out of the stormy ocean. I was quite touched.
44. Returning to the squadron in the last week in January 1944 we were given an aeroplane
for ourselves and thus a ground crew dedicated to our craft. This was "C Charlie". She took us to
Berlin twice before the end of the month, on the 27th and 30th. I have notes of two attacks by
night fighters on the 30th, one on the 27th, both failing to discommode us The first trip took 8
hours, the second only 6 hrs 30 mins The length of the trip depended on the course the bomber
force was told to follow. These courses were elaborately designed to confuse the Germans about
our final destination and prevent them lying in wait for us along our route, and not infrequently
would add a couple of hours to the journey.
45 In February for some reason there were no visits to Germany. I expect that bad weather
accounted for much , and of course there would be in any case ten days when the moon would be
up and no attacks would be made - attacking on a moonlit night had been found early in the war to
be a big no!-no!, every bit as risky as daylight raids without massive fighter cover, the riskiness of
which the U.S.Air Force had discovered to their great cost. (They stopped operating after a month
or two and were only able to continue when the Mustang fighter was re-engined with a Rolls-Royce
Merlin that enabled it to accompany the daylight bombers all the way to Berlin and make it back
even after a dog-fight.) The Merlins were made for this purpose in the USA, and many US-made
engines were used on the Lancasters known as Mark Ills. Also one must remember that
operational aircrew were granted a weeks leave every six weeks - and incidentally were given a
handsome five shillings a day allowance by Lord Nufffield every day we were on leave. It seems
incredible now, but it really happened. Nuffield would also arrange to pay for a weeks stay at a
hotel during our leave. No-one could say the RAF was not appreciated.
46. In March of 1944 we were over Germany 6 times, Stuttgart twice, Fankfurt twice, Le
Mans to bomb the marshalling yards once (it was aborted because the weather closed in and we
could not be sure we would not hit the French in the town) and once more to Berlin - my last
operation on Bomber Command. We were airborn seven hours, not all of it tranquil.
47 The problem with this last raid was that when we were over Berlin and had just released
the bomb load a night fighter attacked us from in front, a most unusual and difficult manoeuvre
Luckily the alert eighteen-year old engineer, Les Weddle, from his seat beside the pilot, spotted this
dark shadow sweeping up from below, coming towards our starboard wing, and shouted, just as a
gunner would, "Starboard for Chrissake!" . Lou, luckily, was a bag of nerves and reacted like a
startled stag when the call came As he swung us down to the right a single cannon shell hit the
inner starboard engine. Fred Carey, the mid upper gunner, had his turret swung around towards the
front and actually saw the flash as the shell struck and stopped the engine. The effect was to
magnify the speed that the wing was dropping in answer to the pilot's wrench on the control
column so much that the fierce drop sucked the petrol out of the outboard engine's carburettor and
that stopped too. All this we worked out later. At the time all we knew was that the plane had
turned on its back, nose down, two engines stopped on the same side, and was beginning to spin.
48. I was largely unaware of all this, being tucked as I always was behind the curtains of the
navigator's cabin, and found it rather startling when I heard Lou's voice saying "Abandon aircraft!
Abandon aircraft!" I pulled back the cabin curtain to see what was going on and viewed with
amazement the remakable sight of of the twinkling fires blazing far below, all revolving in the field
of view while overhead the giant flares that were fired up by the guns below, to illuminate the
bombing force for the night fighters, blazed with a most unwelcome light. I, like most of my trade,
never looked out during a trip, there was nothing to see that would help us.
49. A Lancaster in a spin is not a warming sight, especially from the inside. To come out of
a spin it needs about thirty thousand feet to recover, but they can never get higher than about
twenty-three thousand, so the pilot has no sensible option but to order everybody out and follow
without delay. It was at this point that my life became really interesting. The navigator's parachute
is supposed to be stored in^special place on the bulk-head - but since the introduction of the
superbly effective radar countermeasure "Windows" there has been a need to carry a huge pile of
brown paper parcels containing strips of silver paper, strips which are cut to the exact wavelength
of the enemy radar. The bomb aimer's cabin has only room for about half of the quantity needed
for a long sortie (it is his job to toss a handful of the stuff down a chute every minute or so) so the
half needed for the return trip is stacked beside the navigator's desk, closing off the parachute clip.
50. Thus most navigators simply keep their parachute pack under their chair That's not
sensible, but the idiocy of it only becomes plain when the aircraft is plunging nose down and the
front escape hatch under the floor at the front of the aircraft is opened.. Although I didn't see it go
it is evident that the thing skated happily over the shiny aluminium floor and dived to freedom out
of the front hatch, along with the bomb-aimer and the flight engineer. Some German hausfrau must
have thought she had a fairy godmother when she was presented with a ten pound packet of finest
white silk that night to sweeten the less welcome assortment of high explosive that was dropping in
the neighbourhood. I contemplated the unbelievable absence of the parachute, oddly calm and
slow to take in the enormity of the problem, with no urge to start appealing to God, Buddha, the
Pope, Mohammed or any other prospective saviour. Meanwhile Lou, as captainJunwilling to leave
before everyone was out, stood there impatiently gesturing. Seeing that 1 was stuck he got back in
his seat and waggled the control column to illustrate that the spin was real and the controls were
useless.
51 Then something very odd happened. There was a sort of bump under the aircraft, just as
if an ack-ack shell had gone oft'near us - but this was not likely, for we had now fallen so far that
the gunners below would have set their fuses to explode way high above us, where the main force
were still flying. However, the bump coincided with a change from the spin, falling like a sycamore
seed, to a spiral dive, very tight but quite different, allowing the wing surfaces to act normally and
the plane to be brought to level flight We were at eight thousand feet, down from over twenty
thousand. As far as we knew, Lou and I were alone on the aeroplane, for the two gunners and the
wireless operator would have followed the drill and exited by the hatch at the rear. We were
heading away from the target.so I stood beside Lou for a few minutes before deciding to get back
to my desk and work out what we should do next.
52. The desk was a shock The steep angle of the spinning plane had cleared not only the
parachute but also my plotting tools, protractor, ruler, pencils and such, even the handy and quite
bulky thing (oddly called a computer) that included a circular slide rule and a device for working
out quickly the effect of wind upon the track Happily the chart, on which the desired tracks had
been plotted, together with the times to turn onto each new course scribbled at each turning point -
these only a rather coarse guide, they had been roughly calculated in the briefing room before we
set off, but it was a heaven sent guide. There was another shock to come, a light up the fuselage,
over my left shoulder, heralded the arrival of Gordon Stromberg the wireless operator!
53. It turned out that the two gunners were still on board, too. Colin Drake had got stuck
when trying to extricate himself from his cramped rear gun-turret and Gordon Stromberg and Fred
Carey had with great gallantry stopped to help him He had had to use his emergency axe to clear
himself and in doing so had cut an oxygen pipe, which would prevent us from climbing to join the
main force - without oxygen we were stuck at low altitude. However, we had the semblance of a
team. In particular, as far as I was concerned, we had the ability to listen on the radio to the half-
hourly broadcasts from base that gave us details of the winds recently encountered by the specialist
Pathfinders leading the main force. Stromberg scribbled them down as they came through and
passed them to me Of course they had no direct relevance since they referred to events two miles
above us, but some indication of what was happening at our level could be inferred from the
information. I still feel that Fred and Gordon should have been awarded gongs for staying to
rescue Colin, they would have had no chance if we had continued to spin down.
54. There were some further alarums including a fire in a piece of electronics housed in the
fuselage but in essence we reached Waterbeach in due course, tired and shaken but in one piece - on
the way back Les and Lou had managed to get the starboard outer engine restarted, so that for
most of the return we had three engines rather than two. It may sound odd but we had in fact been
lucky. It turned out that the winds broadcast to the main force had been badly wrong and the
hundreds of aircraft had found themselves inexplicably flying over the heavily defended Ruhr
valley. It resulted in Bomber Commandjiargest losses of the war. 196 planes were lost
55. For me and for Colin Drake the outcome was that the RAF, following a policy of not
stressing people beyond what the medicos thought was reasonable, found us ground jobs. Colin
was returned to Australia. I was posted to the Air Ministry mess in Hallam Street off Portland
Place to be trained as a meteorologist.^! was put to work in the Met Office in Harwell, still paid as
an aircrew NCO, though forbidden to fly and in effect working as a plotting clerk under the WAAF
corporal. I quite enjoyed the rest but it was rather boring and I seemed to be stuck with a desk-
bound clerical job for the duration,
56. Rescue was soon at hand from an unexpected source. A note was circulated from
Coastal Command saying they sought Met men to volunteer for aircrew duties as Meteorological
Air Observers. I was accepted, no-one thinking to check with the medicos at Air Ministry, and I
happily completed a thousand hours flying before being demobbed - [ had done just 400 hours when
withdrawn from bombing.
57. Life was not without its stirring moments even now I was posted to Turnberry, an
airfield converted from the one time golf course (to which it has now been restored) and I was put
in a crew that had not yet completed their conversion course, captained by a Flying Officer Beagley
When after a few daylight trips to familiarise them with the Hudson aircraft they were told to spend
the evening doing night circuits and bumps 1 excused myself and went to the camp cinema for the
evening. When I came out I was greeted with a solemn handshake by the first fellow I met. "So
sorry!" he said. "So very sorry. You must be quite upset." It turned out that while I was viewing
the film the control tower had watched in horror as Beagley's aircraft on taking off towards Ailsa
Craig had suddenly slipped sideways and fallen into the sea. A sprog pilot had come as near to
writing me off as any German.
58 About two weeks later I was sent for by the adjutant. One body had floated to the
surface and been recovered. It belonged to F/0 Beagley. His wife of only a few months had been
told and so had his parents, with whom she lived. They had asked that his body be sent down to be
buried close by them in Weymouth As the only surviving member of the crew I was to accompany
the coffin, together with an officer of his same rank to represent the Air Force. We did not enjoy
this duty. The family was devasted, I had known Beagley for only the few days he had been at
Turnberry and could tell them nothing of his life on the unit, the accompanying officer had no
recollection of him. We were stiff and correct and I fear of no comfort to the family. We were
asked if we would care to stay for a meal after the burial but we made excuses and left as soon as
we decently could. I realised what a blessing it was that on Bomber Command people who were
killed (which half of us were) did not return to be buried in England and resurrect the distress of the
family who had suffered the shock of the dreaded telegram.
59. I was assigned to a new crew to complete the operational training.. This time the
skipper was a Canadian Warrant Officer, Ken Vear, apparently the only pilot in the RCAF who was
not commissioned. The reason for this victimisation I never knew, but he was a fairly wild lad and
could very well have stepped too far out of line even for the RCAF sometime in the past Our first.
trip together was on the 8th of March 1945 We did eleven training trips together, the last on the 30th of
the month, '^w^y ^
60 On this iast excercise there was another very near squeak. We had flown out in a North-
westerly direction and after a few hours the navigator - of course, another sprog - gave the pilot a
change of course, it being time to turn for home. Like a fool Ken did not think to query the
direction. Unhappily the navigator, whose name I have thankfully forgotten, suggested a course
which took us not in a South-easterly direction but North-easterly The truth became clear a couple
more hours later when a huge howl of horror came up from the navigation desk below our feet
Our navigator had just checked his plot and realised that we were way North of Scotland instead of
approaching Turnberry
61 I scuttled down to the navigation desk to check what was now proposed. The chap now
was aiming to set course toward an airfield on the Hebrides, a long but very narrow string of islands
which we would be approaching end on All too easy to be far enough off course to slip by without
seeing them. The sensible thing was to aim instead for the broad top of Scotland, between Wick
and Cape Wrath, a target about fifty miles across. No matter how innacurate the navigation was
we could surely not miss Scotland.
62. On the way back it was becoming plain that we would be very lucky to reach base
before our petrol ran out The wireless operator reported that flying very low, as we were, he was
unable to contact base, so if we went in to the drink they were not going to be aware of what we
were up to. Should we risk using up more petrol than we could spare in order to gain height? The
answer was - better to just press on, we should just make it. No sooner had this decision been
reached than a cry went up, echoing a poster pasted on the wall in every crew room, in mock
German, alerting us to the signs of a German submarine ^Schnorkel mil shmoke und vake!"
63. Below us was the thin trail of exhaust smoke and the faint wake of the exhaust pipe - the
schnorkel - of a submerged German submarine. The war still had some months to run and ships
were still being sunk. We had no option but to circle and gain height to contact base and then drop
back through the clouds and circle the sub, using our radio to guide a destroyer to its position. We
were boumd to end up in the water I remember saying "If I'm going to have to ditch every
couple of years I'm going to give up this aviating game". No-one laughed.
64. Rescue was at hand once again - before we had even started to circle, climbing, there
came in to view, just visible in the misty bottom of the cloud base, the large bulk of a Halifax
aircraft of Coastal Command, evidently doing what we were just facing up to but which was just the
very thing he was out there for, sub hunting. He waggled his wings in silent greeting, we did
likewise and passed on secure in the knowledge that we had no need to stay. It was just as well. It
must have been a couple of hours later that we saw Scotland, turned left, radio'd Wick airfield, and
landed - and ran out of fuel while we were taxi-ing to the dispersal point! It was the closest of all
close-run things. It was six o'clock in the evening. We had been airborne seven hours, my log
book tells me, probably two hours more than planned. After an hour refuelling we still had two
more hours airborne before reaching Turnberry, were we had set out from
65 We finished this operational training in April and I arrived at 517 Squadron at Brawdy in
West Wales the day the war in Europe was declared at an end, the Eighth of May. An important
date in my later life - Faith's birthday. There was a tremendous party in the mess, no doubt, but I
had arrived with a streaming cold and was in bed for a couple of days.
66 It was announced that the need for long range meteorological observations was no less
than before and neither was the risk attendant on collecting the information - lives were lost
regularly on these squadrons but almost never from enemy action, it was always the result of flying
every trip on schedule regardless of the weather on take off or what was forecast for when we
returned As a result, said the announcement, operational conditions would remain in force for
aircrew This meant a week's leave every six weeks, bacon and egg meals before taking off and
again on landing, bars of chocolate to take on the journey - everything just as in war. No-one
complained.
However there were still casualties, 1 think we lost a crew every month or so, sometimes
from flying into a cumulo-nimbus, a great storm cloud, out at sea, sometimes from hitting a hillside
hidden in cloud on returning. I remember it was a rule that if the visibility was good enough to see
three flares on the runway through the mist we were to take oft' We would radio in from the Bay
of Biscay for instructions about returning, and might be diverted to some other airfield, even,
though it was never my luck, being told to go on to Gibraltar or the Azores if the whole of the UK
was closed.
68. [fit was your luck to get one of these exotic diversions it was understood that you
would bring back a plane full of rarities like bananas, pineapples, and perhaps a stock of liquor for
the messes - although this might be caught for duty on return It was not unknown for the Customs
man to be waiting at the runway and to chase after the plane to be sure nothing was quietly
unloaded into a wagon before he saw it. This was the practice even during the war. None of the
generosity of the Nuffield Trust from His Majesty's Excise men With no threat from the Customs
it was common to make sure that one crew was detailed to make itself familiar with a likely
diversion airfield in Northern Ireland, landing there and while on the ground buying a goodly stock
of Guiness, not always easy to come by in England,
69. The trips were long, nine hours or more, one or two stretching to over eleven. I was
first flying with a pilot called Blatchford, who after three or four months took himself off to a job
with B.O A.C to the envy of many other pilots 1 met him once years later on a flight out to
Singapore, by then a senior captain. He was replaced by F/0 Ron Gunst, who became one of my
closest friends on the squadron, second only to Johnny Buggs, a radio operator with whom I shared
a room. Johnny was a ' regular', who had joined the RAF before the war as a boy entrant, an
apprentice wireless mechanic, and who three years after the war turned up at my flat in Russell
Square and stayed for a year - of which more in due time
70.